Current:Home > InvestJudge Upholds $14 Million Fine in Long-running Citizen Suit Against Exxon in Texas-LoTradeCoin
Judge Upholds $14 Million Fine in Long-running Citizen Suit Against Exxon in Texas
View Date:2024-12-23 20:12:04
A federal judge this week rejected a third appeal by ExxonMobil in the 12-year legal battle over toxic emissions from one of the Texas-based energy giant’s Gulf Coast facilities.
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans upheld a $14.25 million fine—thought to be the largest-ever fine resulting from citizen enforcement of environmental law—in a lawsuit brought by environmental organizations against Exxon’s massive complex in Baytown, some 25 miles outside Houston.
The decision still doesn’t guarantee a conclusion to the long-running case, which Exxon may be able to appeal further.
“It’s frequently in the interest of a company to drag out cases for as long as possible to try and get the other side to give up, but we are not giving up,” said Josh Kratka, senior attorney at the National Environmental Law Center, which represented the plaintiffs in the trial. “We hope this is the end of it.”
The suit was first filed in 2010 by Environment Texas and the Sierra Club under the citizen suit provision of the Clean Air Act, which empowers civilians to sue polluters for violations of federal environmental law.
The plaintiffs originally alleged that 16,386 illegal air emissions events, which Exxon disclosed in its own reports, affected the health of communities around the Baytown refinery. A district court in 2017 ordered the Texas-based energy giant to pay almost $20 million.
Exxon appealed, arguing that not all of those violations could be directly traced to specific health problems. Upon review, the court reduced the number of actionable violations to 3,651 and reduced the fine to $14.25 million. Exxon appealed again, contesting the court’s legal standing and the size of the fine.
“This is a standard tactic. It just goes to show the lengths that polluters will go to to prevent true justice from coming forward,” said Stefania Tomaskovic, director of the Coalition for Environment, Equity and Resilience in Houston. “It’s always a struggle to protect our air when companies have so much money to hire lawyers and citizens are not as well resourced.”
On Tuesday, a federal judge rejected Exxon’s latest appeals. The judge upheld the high fine in part due to elements of the Clean Air Act designed to ensure that paying emissions fines isn’t a cheaper alternative for polluters than building adequate facilities.
“The company delayed implementation of four emission-reducing projects mandated by a 2012 agreement between Exxon and state regulators,” said the court opinion issued this week. “Exxon needed to invest $11.75 million dollars in improvements to comply with its Clean Air Act obligations.”
Founded in 1919, Exxon’s Baytown refinery has the fourth largest production levels in the U.S. and is the second largest Exxon refinery in the world (after the company’s Singapore facility).
Exxon calls its Baytown campus the “largest integrated petrochemical complex in the U.S.” and “one of the most technologically advanced petroleum and petrochemical complexes in the world.” It includes a refinery, two chemical plants, an engineering office and a technology center.
The facility was the site of a major explosion and fire in late December 2021, prompting another lawsuit from local community members.
Exxon did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Thursday.
“Exxon’s Baytown complex is the largest polluter on the Houston Ship Channel,” said Neil Carman, clear air program director for the Lone Star chapter of the Sierra Club, a plaintiff in the case. “Exxon still needs to do more to create cleaner air in the Houston area.”
veryGood! (82)
Related
- Arizona Supreme Court declines emergency request to extend ballot ‘curing’ deadline
- Trump's presidential election win and what it says about the future of cancel culture
- Parked vehicle with gas cylinders explodes on NYC street, damaging homes and cars, officials say
- Retired research chimps to be moved from New Mexico to a Louisiana sanctuary
- Trump's election has women swearing off sex with men. It's called the 4B movement.
- Parked vehicle with gas cylinders explodes on NYC street, damaging homes and cars, officials say
- Inter Miami vs. Atlanta live updates: Will Messi fend off elimination in MLS Cup Playoffs?
- Years of shortchanging elections led to Honolulu’s long voter lines
- Candidates line up for special elections to replace Virginia senators recently elected to US House
- Kirk Herbstreit's late dog Ben gets emotional tribute on 'College GameDay,' Herbstreit cries on set
Ranking
- Taylor Swift's Mom Andrea Gives Sweet Nod to Travis Kelce at Chiefs Game
- 3 arrested on charges of elder abuse, Medicaid fraud in separate Arkansas cases
- Phoenix Suns' Kevin Durant out at least two weeks with left calf strain
- Georgia governor declares emergency in 23 counties inundated with heavy rain and flooding
- Let Demi Moore’s Iconic Fashion Give You More Inspiration
- Democrat Marie Gluesenkamp Perez wins reelection in Washington’s closely watched 3rd District
- James Van Der Beek, Father of 6, Got Vasectomy Before Cancer Diagnosis
- Georgia governor declares emergency in 23 counties inundated with heavy rain and flooding
Recommendation
-
Judith Jamison, a dancer both eloquent and elegant, led Ailey troupe to success over two decades
-
Republican US Rep. Eli Crane wins second term in vast Arizona congressional district
-
Georgia vs Ole Miss live updates: How to watch game, predictions, odds, Top 25 schedule
-
Democrat Andrea Salinas wins reelection in Oregon’s 6th District
-
Whoopi Goldberg calling herself 'a working person' garners criticism from 'The View' fans
-
Pretty Little Liars' Brant Daugherty Reveals Which NSFW Movie He Hopes His Kids Don't See
-
13 Holiday Gifts for Men That Will Make Them Say 'Wow'
-
NYC man is charged with insurance fraud in staged car crash captured by dashcam